​
The first known pastors were members of the Wisconsin Lutheran Synod.  Later, the pastors came from Friedens Church of Port Washington.

​1860               Rev. William Damman
1865                Rev. Gausewitz
1866                Rev. R. Baart
1868                Rev. Fred A. Kleinert
1872                Rev. Julius Frank
1881                Rev. G. Ebling
1884                Rev. Eugene C.F. Ernst
1888                Rev. Edward Schrader
1893                Rev. E. Zech
1894                Rev. John Heinrich
1894                Rev. B. Muench
 
Pastors engaged by our church who served our congregation from the time it became a self-sustaining congregation to the present time:

1894-1897       Rev. Carl A. Schlegel
1897-1907       Rev. Carl B. Schuh
1907-1913       Rev. Kuno A. Kuenne
1913-1917       Rev. Julius Ziegler
1917-1926       Rev. John (Johannes) Schaefer
1926-1931       Rev. Ernst Holder
1931-1940       Dr. Gustav A. Hensel
1941-1945       Rev. Herbert T. Tetzlaff
1945-1950       Rev. Milton L. Straube
1950-1966       Rev. Henry E. Totzke
1966-1967       Rev. Edward J. Busse (interim)
1967-1970       Rev. Richard W. Sather
1970-1980       Rev. Joseph W. Charlebois
1980-1981       Rev. Edwin Stanford (interim)
1981-1982       Rev. George E. Behrens (interim)
1982-1983       Rev. Arnold Schultz (interim)
1983-1992       Rev. Donald J. Niederfrank
1992-1993       Rev. James L. Thomson (interim)
1993-2000       Rev. George O. Jorenby
2000-2002       James Liebnow & Dick Hotchkin (interims)
2002-2012       Rev. Donald E. Ellerman
2012-2013       Rev. Rebecca A. Johnston (interim)
2013-2015       Rev. Brian Damrow
2015-2018       Rev. Craig Modahl (Bridge Pastor)
2018-2019       Rev. Michelle Freeman
​2020-                Rev. Susan Drake